
To whom it may concern,
I am a local photographer and CTA rider who uses the CTA on a daily basis and have never until now had a bad experience with any CTA employee. On 7/16/08 at approximately 5pm I was riding in the first car of a brown line train traveling southbound. I believe it was located somewhere between Diversey and Armitage. I'm not sure what the route number was, but the car I was in was numbered #3432. The car was relatively empty, and impressed with the view from the forward window I took out my camera to take a few shots. I have previously read the CTA's posted policy regarding photography and I've taken quite a few shots always staying in accordance with those rules and trying not to be a nuisance to either fellow rider or employee. During a slow point where the train had stopped to wait for clearance the operator opened the door and very rudely and aggressively told me I was breaking the CTA's photography rules and that there was no photography permitted inside the trains. I do not believe I was being disruptive in any way to the operation of the train, nor do I believe I was breaking any rules as they are posted publicly. I told him I did not believe what he was saying to be correct and he informed me I would be removed from the train if I did not comply. He made some call on his walkie talkie about me, but no one removed me from the train. I presume because I in fact had not broken any rules.
I have no issues with photography policies designed to safeguard the well being of employees or riders. However I do not believe that quietly taking a photo out of a window interferes with the safety of the train. And even if it did I think it should somehow be included in the posted policy. Even if was unknowingly in the wrong I think that the operator in question (a hispanic male I presumed to be in his late 20s or early thirties) could use a lesson in tact and manners. Also if the CTA is that anti-photography then it should reflect in the posted policies. Ironically the same train operator passed by another photographer on a platform snapping away and he didn't seem to mind that at all. As a photographer I do not understand anti-photography policies that aren't in direct relation to safety, and as a paying customer I do not appreciate unnecessarily rude behavior.
Regards
Joshua Mitchell
The CTA's posted policy as of 7/16/08:CTA Photography Policy:
The general public is allowed to take snapshots in public areas.
I consider myself the general public.Equipment such as lighting, tripods, cables, etc. is not allowed - except in instances where commercial and professional photographers enter into contractual agreements with CTA.
Non of that here, just a crappy lens baby.Photographers are not allowed to enter or photograph non-public areas of CTA stations.
Train cars seem pretty public to me.Photographers are prohibited from obstructing transit operations, interfering with customers and blocking doors or stairs.
Don't think I was doing any of this either.CTA personnel may evaluate the actions of photographers on a case by case basis to determine if a photographer is in compliance with guidelines. If a determination is made that the photographer is not in compliance, CTA personnel may ask them to stop.
Oh... the loop hole...